http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2010/9/8/nation/6999268&sec=nation
A tame punishment
THE STAR SAYS . . .
WE had a chance to severely punish a notorious wildlife trader and send a signal that we mean business in repairing our unwelcome reputation as an international hub for this illegal trade. But we blew it.
The penalty meted out by the courts to Anson Wong is a mere slap on the wrist, and reflects our inability to get tough with wildlife criminals. When enacted, the International Trade in Endangered Species Act 2008 had drawn applause for its harsh penalties: a whopping maximum fine of RM100,000 for each animal smuggled.
Unfortunately, Wong was fined only RM2,000 for each of the 95 boa constrictors stuffed into his suitcase. So he got away with a RM190,000 fine – an amount which the businessman could easily cough out – instead of what could have been a deterrent penalty of close to RM1mil. The fines pale in comparison with the market price of boa constrictors of between RM200 and RM4,000 each on the Internet.
His jail term of six months is also disappointing as the Act provides for a maximum of seven years.
Paltry penalties have always been a scourge in the war against wildlife trafficking. The newly implemented Act is meant to overcome this. But when it comes to sentencing, the ball is in the court of the presiding judge. And it appears the seriousness of wildlife crime is not being fully appreciated despite the Asean Wildlife Enforcement Network and the Federal Courts of Malaysia holding a two-day workshop specifically for the judiciary last year.
Wong had an import permit to bring the snakes into Penang but not re-export permits to Indonesia. So he was caught on a technicality.
But closer scrutiny reveals unanswered questions. Isn’t it illegal to pack live animals into checked-in luggage under International Air Transport Association rules, not to mention endanger the lives of passengers? And what about the fact that Wong has a previous conviction in the United States, which landed him 71 months in jail and fined US$60,000 (RM187,000).
The man who has earned the monikers “Asian wildlife kingpin” and “Pablo Escobar of the wildlife trade” also had two rhinoceros vipers and a matamata turtle in his bag but there was no case here as these are not trade-regulated species.
Also, the charge against Wong did not specify the sub-species of boa constrictors. All boa constrictors, except for one sub-species, come under Appendix II of the Conven-tion on International Trade in Endangered Species (Cites); this means they can be traded, but with permits.
Only an expert can differentiate between the sub-species, so what if Wong’s boa constrictors were actually the Appendix I sub-species, the Boa constrictor occidentalis, which is banned from trade? Perhilitan (Wildlife and National Parks Department) could have built a stronger case if it knew for sure.
And did Perhilitan investigate the source of the boa constrictors? Were they really captive-bred as claimed by Wong, and not wild-caught? Dealers routinely use the description “captive-bred” in order to obtain permits, so there could be another offence here.
Yet another unanswered question is why a convicted wildlife trafficker still holds permits to keep and trade in endangered animals. Perhilitan should immediately revoke all licences issued to Wong.
For sure, Wong’s “bag act” is not the first. Wildlife crime investigators say stuffing animals in luggage is the smugglers’ preferred modus operandi, along with concealment in shipments of legally approved animals. Unlike birds which can be noisy, reptiles are usually not drugged when packed into bags. But the animals will surely show up in airport X-ray scanners. So how did Wong’s bag get through the Penang airport security?
We need to ask ourselves: Should we condone the trading and keeping of wild animals? Or is it too much to expect Malaysians to care? On the whole, we don’t particularly treat domesticated animals well, so what more creatures of the wild.
Related Stories:
Wildlife trade is still roaring
=======================================
http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2010/9/8/nation/6999419&sec=nation
Wednesday September 8, 2010
Wildlife trade is still roaring
PETALING JAYA: Wildlife trafficker Anson Wong may be behind bars, but an animal collector claims several pet shops in the Klang Valley are still receiving their supply from sources related to him.
Nicholas Lee (not his real name), who has a collection of over 50 exotic pets, claimed that a pet shop owner told him that its supply of wild animals would not be cut off although Wong had been sentenced to six months in jail.
“In my years of collecting exotic animals, the pet shops that I frequent told me they received their supplies from Penang.
“It is a fact that there is only one wildlife supplier in Penang – Anson Wong,” said the 33-year-old, who started his hobby by keeping a few iguanas when he was in Form Four.
Lee, a marketing manager, said his pets were obtained legally and he had licences for each of them.
His exotic collection includes snakes, frogs, lizards and tarantula spiders.
Lee said wildlife collectors kept such animals because it was fascinating to see how they grew and behaved.
On Monday, Wong — described as the ‘’Pablo Escobar of the wildlife trade’’ — was jailed six months and fined a total of RM190,000 for smuggling 95 snakes without a permit.
Wong was caught at the KL International Airport on Aug 26 while trying to smuggle boa constrictors without a permit to Jakarta.
He pleaded guilty to the offence.
Natural Resources and Environment Minister Datuk Seri Douglas Uggah Embas said his ministry would appeal and seek a tougher penalty against Wong as he believed the wildlife trafficker got off lightly.
The ministry’s senior legal adviser, Faridz Gohim Abdullah, who acted for the prosecution in Wong’s case, said the ministry should file their appeal within 14 days after the date of sentencing.
“However, this matter is now being handled by the Attorney-General’s Chambers,” he said.
Wong’s lawyer, M. Sivam, said he had yet to receive instructions from his client to appeal against his sentence.
Related Story:
A tame punishment
=============================================
http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2010/9/8/nation/20100908102703&sec=nation
Appeal filed against Anson Wong’s sentence
BY LOURDES CHARLES
PETALING JAYA: The Attorney-General’s Chambers has filed an appeal against the sentenced meted out to “Lizard King” Anson Wong for smuggling snakes.
The appeal is seeking for a heavier sentence against Wong, who was jailed six months and fined a total of RM190,000 by the Sepang Sessions Court for smuggling 95 snakes without a permit.
This is the first time the 52-year-old Penangite, who was caught at the KL International Airport on Aug 26 while trying to smuggle the boa constrictors to Jakarta, has been sentenced in Malaysia.
Various conservation groups had expressed disappointment with the sentence, saying that Malaysia should show that it was serious in tackling wildlife trafficking.
Related Stories:
A tame punishment
Wildlife trade is still roaring
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Read more to learn what can you do about this problem: